This pada continues the refutation of opposing philosophical systems, deepening the critique of non-Vedantic views. It examines more refined arguments from schools such as Sāṅkhya, Yoga, Vaiśeṣika, and various Buddhist traditions, addressing their explanations of causation, the self, and the nature of reality. The goal is to show that these systems cannot consistently account for the unity, continuity, and intelligibility of existence.
A key discussion focuses on the theory of causation. The sutras argue against the idea that the effect is entirely different from its cause or that the world arises from multiple independent principles. Instead, they reinforce the Vedantic position that the universe emerges from Brahman as its material and efficient cause, preserving continuity between cause and effect.
The pada also examines doctrines that deny a stable self or ultimate substratum, particularly certain Buddhist views of momentariness and emptiness. These are rejected on the grounds that knowledge, memory, and experience presuppose an enduring principle. Without such a foundation, neither perception nor liberation can be coherently explained.
Further, the sutras challenge the idea that liberation can be achieved through purely intellectual or mechanical means without recognising Brahman. Systems that rely solely on logic, ritual, or dualistic principles are shown to be limited, as they do not lead to the direct knowledge of the ultimate reality.
Overall, this pada strengthens the Vedantic position by systematically dismantling alternative explanations of reality. It demonstrates that only the doctrine of Brahman as the single, intelligent, and underlying cause of the universe can resolve philosophical contradictions and provide a coherent account of existence and liberation.
Original Text